The ravages of the status quo…
Posted November 19, 2013on:
Good afternoon Widdershin friends. I’m cheating today. I had started a post about this very subject and then I ran across this better written synopsis. I’m a firm believer in only serving the best.
This comes from the Washington Post Wonkblog and it was published yesterday. (I wouldn’t want anyone to mistake me for a varmit-headed plagiarizing Rand Paul.)
As often happens, the prospect of reform has led to a sudden eruption of affection for the health-care status quo. The airwaves are alive with impassioned protests against the idea that anyone might change a market that relies on discriminating against the old, the sick, the female, and people who don’t read the fine print of insurance policies. This is the best health care in the world, you know.
The Commonwealth Fund’s latest survey of international health systems stands as a refreshing reality check. Their data compares the U.S. to Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, and the United Kingdom on a host of health-system measures, both objective (like diabetes amputations) and subjective (like satisfaction). The results are a reminder of why reform is so badly needed.
Start with cost. Americans spend 17.7 percent of GDP on health care. No one else spends even 12 percent. Let’s make that more concrete: If Americans only spent 12 percent of GDP on health care we would have saved $893 billion in 2012.
The reason isn’t that Americans get more health care than anyone else. We have more uninsured than anyone else. We have fewer physicians per capita than anyone but the Japanese. We go to the doctor less often than anyone but the Swiss. We don’t have more hospital beds than other developed countries, and when we do go to the hospital, we don’t stay longer.
But we do pay more for the privilege. The average hospital stay costs more than $21,000 in the U.S. It costs only $8,363 in France. (See “Why an MRI costs $1,080 in America and $280 in France“.)
Nor do we receive better, swifter, or more flexible service. For all the talk of waiting lines in foreign countries, America is second only to Canada in the number of adults reporting difficulty getting a next-day appointment when they’re sick. Americans also find it unusually difficult to get after-hours care, and by a wide margin, Americans are more likely than residents of any other developed country to report that cost is a barrier to getting health care. Oh, and Americans are more likely to report being the victim of a medical error.
There are some bright spots for the American medical system. Residents of the U.S. find it easy to get quick appointments with specialists, and only citizens of France, Germany, the Netherlands, and Switzerland report that they can get schedule elective surgeries as rapidly.
The data on quality, however, is more mixed. Americans lead the world in five-year survival for breast cancer. But we lag competitor nations on diabetes amputations. And we’re only middle-of-the-pack on surviving myocardial infractions (a common kind of heart attack).
This is, to say the least, a pretty poor performance for a health-care system that costs so much more than any other. And it shows up in public surveys. Only 29 percent of Americans say the health-care system works well and only minor changes are necessary. That’s lower than anywhere save Australia. Meanwhile, 29 percent say the system needs to be completely rebuilt. That’s higher than anywhere else in the survey, period.
The point of my post is quite simply, “Vision without a plan of execution is a hallucination.” The Affordable Care Act is proof positive of this aphorism. There is a reason leaders are often called “Chief Executives” — not the least of which is their overriding need to be able to execute.
The inability of the administration to execute on the ACA has automatically conjured up longing for the status quo which isn’t bad if you are one blessed with status. For the rest of us, the status quo is the enemy of progressive change.
Yes change is painful, but not near the price of over 40,000 deaths a year from inadequate health care.
This is an open thread.
9 Responses to "The ravages of the status quo…"
Comments are closed.